Neuroscientist Reveals How Meditation Affects Our Brain
-
by
Ree Webster
A novel new approach that uses existing technology to look into the effects of meditation is contributing to growing body of official documentation that shows this holistic practice does indeed offer numerous health benefits for the body and mind.
Depression is a condition that affects a rapidly growing number of the population. The number of American’s reported to be clinically depressed rose from 16.1 million in 2015, to over 21 million in 2024; a surprising 8%. But despite the numerous different treatments available the efficacy isn’t consistent and many patients can find none of the typical solutions work for them.
Benjamin Shapero, an instructor in psychiatry at Harvard Medical School (HMS) and a psychologist at Massachusetts General Hospital’s (MGH) Depression Clinical and Research Program, said:
“Many people don’t respond to the frontline interventions… Individual cognitive behavioral therapy is helpful for many people; antidepressant medications help many people. But it’s also the case that many people don’t benefit from them as well. There’s a great need for alternative approaches.”
Together with Gaëlle Desbordes, a neuroscientist and radiology instructor at MGH’s Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Shapero endeavors to explore an alternative approach: ‘mindfulness-based meditation’.
Meditation has long been a topic of much anecdotal evidence that touted its numerous health benefits, and as the information age began to flourish, the practice slowly began gathering credible scientific support. Then, in recent years, the public interest surrounding mindfulness meditation quickly soared, likely thanks to the growing acceptance in the scientific community.
The number of randomized controlled trials has increased dramatically from the loan study conducted from 1995-1997, to 11 studies from 2004-2006, to a whopping 216 carried out from 2013-2015. The increasing number of studies clearly show the practice can help combat several physical and mental conditions. This includes anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder and even chronic pain, irritable bowel syndrome, fibromyalgia, and psoriasis.
Some studies show that after just two weeks, meditation can begin having a positive effect on the brain, an effect that can be demonstrated via MRI scans. However, displaying this activity wasn’t always thought to be possible since these signals are extremely weak and only last a fraction of a second. However, researchers found that these signals became greatly amplified when meditating, allowing them to see the activity light up when scanned.
Functional Neuroanatomy of Meditation
It’s important to note that not all experts agree with the findings, some call into the question alleged experimental designed studies, and small sample sizes. However, the ever growing amount of research that all corroborates the results would seem to suggest otherwise; especially when taking into the account the wealth of anecdotal evidence that also agrees. Desbordes said.
“There are a few applications where the evidence is believable. But the effects are by no means earth-shattering… “We’re talking about moderate effect size, on par with other treatments, not better. And then there’s a bunch of other things under study with preliminary evidence that is encouraging but by no means conclusive. I think that’s where it’s at. I’m not sure that is exactly how the public understands it at this point.”
Nevertheless Desbordes, and likely thousands of other researchers around the globe, vow to continue the research into the effects of meditation with the hopes of developing complete understanding of the practice and its benefits. Desbordes added:
“We know those brain systems involved with interoception, and we know those involved with rumination and depression. I want to test, after taking MBCT, whether we see changes in these networks, particularly in tasks specifically engaging them,” Desbordes said.
Other researchers studying the effects of meditation include Sara Lazar, who used fMRI scans to prove thickening of the brain after eight-week meditation courses, and Zev Schuman-Olivier, the director of the Center for Mindfulness and Compassion, who represents one of a dozen investigators that include major institutions such as MGH’s Benson-Henry Institute, HMS and Brigham and Women’s Hospital’s Osher Center for Integrative Medicine and the Harvard-affiliated Cambridge Health Alliance, all of who are working together to develop our understanding of meditation and its effects on the mind and body.
Experts note a couple of hurdles that research may need to overcome, for example, studies will need to sort through the many variations of the practice, and attempt to arrive on an accepted clinical and scientific standard.
This is where mindfulness-based meditation is thought to be ideal, as it incorporates techniques derived from religious practices, that not only provide spiritual benefits, but also real world benefits.
Furthermore, mindfulness mediation may help bridge the gap between religion and secular association. Whilst some practicing may do so with religious connotations, these methods may still be scientifically meaningful and should still be explored.
What is Mindfulness-Based Meditation?
Mindfulness-based meditation is a practice that focuses on cultivating awareness of the present moment through non-judgmental observation of thoughts, feelings, and sensations. Unlike traditional meditation, which often emphasizes relaxation or achieving a specific mental state, mindfulness-based meditation centers on developing intentional awareness and acceptance of one’s experiences.
Developed in the late 1970s by Dr. Jon Kabat-Zinn at the University of Massachusetts Medical School, it is widely used to manage stress, anxiety, depression, and chronic pain. Benefits include improved mental clarity, emotional regulation, and overall well-being. This evidence-based practice combines ancient mindfulness principles with modern psychology for therapeutic applications.
Desbordes explains more variations raise interest in potential benefits; for example, ‘compassion meditation’, designed to increase caring for those around us, is just one of many more stress-relief meditation techniques perfect for such research, and this is far from the only variation. With so many methods and techniques, the most effective practice will likely consist of a mix of the best, precisely what such research hopes to discover.
Desbordes voiced her focus on finding out precisely what mindful meditation can do to combat depression. She noted that if researchers can identify what elements are practical, the therapy could easily be refined to be much more successful.
Shapero is also interested in using the research to refine meditation treatments. Since some patients benefit from mindfulness meditation and some do not, he’d like to understand what differentiates those who benefit from the practice from those who don’t. Desbordes concluded:
“Once we know which ingredients are successful, we can do more of that and less, maybe, of the parts that are less effective.”